Sixteen Years Old
The old access door will not open.
I shoulder it once, more out of habit than optimism. The wood gives a familiar little shudder in its frame, but the latch does not budge.
I try again.
Nothing.
“It might surrender if you glare harder.”
I turn.
Merren is standing half a flight below me with one hand on the rail, breathing a little harder than someone who absolutely did not hurry to catch up. He has grown into his limbs since I last saw him regularly. At eleven, he had been all elbows, long fingers, and a perpetually startled expression whenever one of us told him another invisible rule of aristocratic life.
At sixteen, he mostly looks amused.
“They locked it,” he says.
“I gathered.”
“Last year.”
“That information would have been more useful before I tried dislocating my shoulder.”
“I wanted to see whether you still did that.”
“Did what?”
“Assume doors are the ones being unreasonable.”
I look at the door, then at him, and I arch my brow haughtily.
“It is being unreasonable.”
Merren laughs.
The sound slips into something in me before I can stop it.
I had forgotten that laugh. Or perhaps not forgotten. I simply have not heard it in long enough that the recognition comes before the memory.
He gestures back down the stairs. “Come on. There’s another way now.”
I follow him.
The stone stairwell smells exactly as it used to, dusty and cool beneath the warmer air drifting down from the roof. Voices seep through one of the classroom doors below. Somebody is reciting trade law in a tone that makes dying sound like an appealing elective.
At the next landing, Merren turns somewhere I never would have.
There is a narrow service corridor behind a door I remember always being locked. Now the lock itself is gone. He pushes through, ducks under a low beam, and climbs three steep wooden steps toward a square hatch.
I stop behind him.
“You found this?”
“Thomas did.”
“That is worse.”
“He fell through a laundry chute first.”
“That is better.”
Merren looks over his shoulder, grinning.
“We had to pull him out by the ankles. Nearly lost his trousers.”
I can picture it so clearly that I laugh.
The invitation had come from Thomas too. A folded note sent to the house six days ago, addressed in handwriting that had not improved at all.
Old times’ sake. Roof. Fifth bell. Don’t become respectable before then.I had left it on my desk for two days. Then moved it to the windowsill. Then back to the desk.
Uncle Cyril had noticed it eventually. I had not told him I wanted to go. I had only mentioned that everyone was getting together again, as if I were reporting weather. He had been pleased anyway. Not loudly. That would have made me refuse on principle. Just enough.
And lately there have been more things I want to do.
That still feels strange.
Riding helps.
There are mornings now when I wake already thinking about Bramble at the edge-city stable, whether she will try to bite the stableboy again, whether the roads will be dry enough to take her farther out.
Sometimes I spend half a day on horseback and realize, afterward, that I was happy for most of it.
The first few times that happened, I felt sick with guilt.
Now I only feel sick sometimes.
Progress.
Apparently.
Merren shoulders the hatch open. Warm air spills down over us, carrying stone dust, smoke, wine, and moonweed.
Then Emily’s laugh. I know it immediately. Merren climbs through and reaches back.
For half a second I only look at his hand.
The first time I brought him up here, I had been the one getting him through the door.
He had worn an expensive new coat and asked whether climbing onto school roofs was something aristocratic children routinely did.
I told him yes.
Thomas told him no.
Clara told Thomas to stop ruining things.
Merren wiggles his fingers at me now.
“You planning to live in the stairwell?”
I take his hand. “No.”
He pulls me the last step up, and the roof opens around me.
For a moment, nobody notices.
The light is the first thing I see.
Late afternoon has gone soft and yellow over Central Embrathis, catching along pale roofs and high windows, turning every west-facing piece of stone warm at the edges. The sun has dropped low enough that the taller buildings cast long blue-gray shadows into the streets below, but twilight has not arrived yet. Where the city drops away in layers, the farmlands have been washed in muted yellow light, great blue shadows cast by houses and clumps of trees. The sunsnare bay glitters on the horizon.
The roof itself is familiar enough to make something under my ribs ache.
The low parapet.
The chipped corner where Orlian once attempted a jump she absolutely could not make.
A blackened smear near the wall from Thomas dropping a coal ember and insisting, with mounting desperation, that it had been there for decades.
There are new things too. Cushions, a folded blanket, two bottles tucked beneath the parapet, a wooden crate that looks as though it has spent several seasons outdoors.
And Merren drops down into the corner I always used to sit in as naturally as breathing.
“Raenie?” Clara sees me first.
Her whole face changes.
Then Thomas twists around from where he is sitting cross-legged on the blanket. “Well, fuck me.”
“Please no,” I say.
Emily turns so fast she nearly elbows Orlian in the face. “Araenia!”
“Oh, good,” I say. “You do remember me.”
Thomas is already getting to his feet. “Debatable.” He crosses the roof and catches me by both shoulders, looking me over with exaggerated suspicion. “You’re taller.”
“You’re uglier.”
“There she is.”
He pulls me into a hug before I can decide whether I want one.
I let him.
Thomas has always hugged like he expects resistance and has prepared accordingly. When he releases me, Emily takes his place. Hers is quicker, smelling of something floral and expensive beneath the moonweed caught in her clothes.
“You look gorgeous.”
“You’re drunk.”
“Barely.”
“She’s lying,” Merren says from behind her.
Emily does not even turn.
“You promised not to embarrass me for once.”
“I promised nothing of the kind.”
“You nodded.”
“I was chewing.”
She reaches blindly behind herself and throws something at him.
Merren catches the cork one-handed.
I look between them, one brow arched.
Emily catches me looking.
“What?”
My brows rise, but I shrug. “Nothing.”
“Don’t make that face.”
“I’m not making a face.”
“You absolutely are.”
Merren says, “She is.”
She points. “You stay out of this.”
“I thought I was already in it.”
Emily smiles at him before she can stop herself.
He smiles back.
I file that away.
Clara reaches me more quietly.
For a moment, we only look at each other. Her hair is longer now. Pinned back differently. She has a little gold ring in one ear that I don't remember.
“Hi,” she says.
“Hi.”
Then she hugs me.
I close my eyes, only for a second. Clara used to come to the house, mre than the others. At first every few days.
Then once a week.
Then whenever our mothers happened to arrange something nearby.
Then not at all.
Her arms still feel familiar.
When she steps away, she keeps one hand around my wrist for another moment.
“I’m glad you came.” Something about how simply she says it makes me believe her.
“Thomas threatened me.”
“I wrote one note,” Thomas protests.
“Threateningly.”
“You’re welcome.”
Clara smiles.
Then I look toward Orlian.
She has not come over. She is sitting against the western parapet with one leg bent, Emily’s abandoned cup beside her, looking perfectly comfortable in the center of everyone else without physically occupying it.
That is new.
Or perhaps it is not.
Orlian always had a way of making people orient toward her. At twelve, she could turn an argument about school lunches into a referendum on municipal planning and somehow make all of us participate.
Now it has sharpened. She looks older than the others somehow. Not in her face, but in the way she holds still.
Her hair is cut at her jaw, and while it makes her look stunning, I mourn for a moment. I liked it long. That thought is so automatic and so deeply embarrassing that I nearly turn around and climb back through the hatch.
I had a terrible crush on Orlian when I was twelve.
Catastrophic.
Humiliating.
I once changed dresses three times because I knew she would be at Clara’s birthday supper and then spent the entire evening pretending clothes were a stupid thing to care about.
Clara noticed.
Clara noticed everything.
Orlian smiles at me now.
“Hey, Raenie.” Her voice is a little lower.
Wonderful.
“Orlian.”
“That’s all I get?”
“What were you expecting?”
“A tearful reunion.”
“You first.”
Her smile widens.
Thomas groans. “No.”
I glance at him. “We’ve exchanged four words.”
“I know the signs.”
Orlian looks toward him. “You invited her.”
“I know. I was a fool.”
“Still are,” Merren says.
Clara snorts.
Thomas points at him. “I brought you into respectable society.”
“No,” I say.
Everyone looks at me. I nod toward Merren.
“I did.” Merren lifts his cup.
“She did.”
Thomas looks wounded. “After everything I’ve done for you.”
“You put me in a laundry chute.”
“You climbed into that yourself.”
“Because you said there was a shortcut.”
“There was.”
“To the laundry.”
Emily starts laughing.
Clara joins her.
Then Merren says something about a hat.
Thomas tells him to shut up.
Clara immediately says, “The green one?”
That destroys all three of them.
I stand there while Thomas bends double, Clara grabs Merren’s shoulder, and Merren tries unsuccessfully to explain something through laughter.
Emily looks at me.
“You don’t know about the hat.”
“No.”
“You’re blessed.”
“What hat?”
“Don’t,” Thomas says.
Merren is already pulling breath back into his lungs.
“It was during Rector Bell’s spring address.”
Thomas points at him.
“I will kill you.”
“You wore it voluntarily.”
“I was coerced.”
“By whom?”
“Circumstance.”
Clara says, “He lost a bet.”
“It was not a bet.”
“It involved cards.”
“That does not make everything a bet.”
“What was the hat?” I ask.
Merren looks delighted that I asked.
“Velvet.”
Thomas closes his eyes.
“Green velvet.”
Emily starts laughing before anything else happens.
“With a feather,” Clara adds.
“It was not a feather.”
“It was absolutely a feather.”
“It was decorative plumage.”
I stare at Thomas.
“You wore a green velvet hat with decorative plumage to Rector Bell’s spring address.”
“For seven minutes.”
“He bowed,” Merren says.
Thomas rounds on him.
“I had to bow.”
Clara is crying now.
“With the feather.”
“Decorative plumage.”
I laugh, I can't help it.
Thomas looks at me with betrayed dignity. “You weren’t even there.”
“No,” I say, still laughing. “Apparently I didn’t need to be.”
Something flickers across his face.
Gone too quickly for me to decide what it was.
Then he points at an empty cushion near Clara.
“Sit down before you become unbearable standing up.”
I do, but not in my old place. Just near it. That should not matter. It mostly doesn't.
Emily passes me her cup without asking what I want. I take it because refusing would make more of it than taking it. The wine is sweet, at least, but I'm craving something stronger.
“You still drink this?” I ask her.
Emily looks offended. “It has fruit in it.”
“That is not a defense.”
“It is to me.”
Merren reaches over and takes the cup out of my hand.
“Don’t let her choose wine.”
Emily leans across me to smack his arm.
“You drink it.”
“I drink anything you hand me.”
“I know.”
There is a beat there.
Small.
Private.
Clara catches it too and smiles into her own cup.
Emily notices Clara noticing.
“Oh, shut up.”
“I didn’t say anything.”
“You were about to.”
Clara’s smile grows.
Thomas says, “She has been about to for three months.”
Merren throws the cork at him.
This one misses.
The conversation moves without asking whether I am ready for it.
That is familiar too.
Thomas is complaining about a tutor.
Clara interrupts to tell him the tutor is right.
Merren immediately takes Thomas’s side, apparently on principle.
Orlian asks one question from across the blanket and somehow all three of them stop talking over each other long enough to answer.
Emily leans over to murmur something close to her ear.
Orlian listens.
Her expression changes.
Not much.
Enough that I know whatever Emily said mattered.
“What?” Thomas asks.
“Nothing,” Orlian says.
Emily looks smug.
Thomas points between them.
“I hate when you do that.”
“Do what?”
“That.”
“Very descriptive.”
“You know.”
Orlian takes Emily’s cup and drinks from it.
Emily does not react.
I look away toward the city.
A carriage moves slowly below.
Two riders pass it on the inside.
My eyes follow the horses automatically.
“You still ride?” Merren asks.
I glance back. “Of course.”
He raises both eyebrows. “Every day still?”
“Most days.”
“Huh.”
“What?”
“Nothing. I didn’t know you were really that into horses.”
I almost say,
you never asked.Instead I take my cup back from him. “I go out toward the edge stable.”
“What are you riding?”
“A chestnut mare mostly. Bramble.”
Thomas says, “That sounds unpleasant.”
“She is.”
“Then why ride her?”
“Because she’s good.”
“Your standards for companionship remain baffling.”
“They’ve improved, actually.”
Clara laughs.
Merren asks, “Does she bite?”
“Yes.”
“Of course she does.”
Emily says, “Raenie always liked horrible horses.”
“Interesting coming from someone drinking this wine.”
She gasps.
Orlian looks over. “What’s wrong with Bramble?”
The question is directed at me.
Just me.
And there it is again.
That old sensation.
Orlian asking because she expects an answer worth hearing.
“Nothing is wrong with Bramble.”
“You just said she bites.”
“She bites idiots.”
Thomas says, “That seems subjective.”
“It isn’t.”
Orlian tips her head.
“So she’s discerning.”
“Exactly.”
“She’d hate Thomas.”
“She would.”
Thomas throws up both hands. “Wonderful. Glad you came.”
I grin.
Orlian smiles back.
For several minutes after that, it is almost easy.
Not because nothing has changed.
Because I stop counting the changes.
Someone passes the moonweed.
Thomas starts an argument about whether the new western skybridge is ugly.
Merren says it is practical.
Clara says practicality does not excuse making half the skyline look like scaffolding.
Orlian says that is not what scaffolding looks like.
I tell her she has missed the point.
She turns toward me immediately. “What point?”
“That something can function and still be hideous.”
“That is not what Clara said.”
“It is exactly what Clara said.”
Clara lifts one finger. “It was.”
Orlian ignores her. “Then define hideous.”
“I’m not defining hideous for you.”
“You brought it up.”
“Clara brought it up.”
“You defended it.”
“Because she’s right.”
“She usually isn’t.”
“Excuse me?” Now Clara is involved.
Thomas groans and lies backward across the blanket.
Merren starts laughing.
Emily takes the moonweed from between Orlian’s fingers while Orlian is still talking to me. Nobody notices except me. Orlian does not even look.
She keeps arguing. For a little while, I am twelve again in the least dangerous way possible.
Then Emily whispers something to Orlian. Orlian stops mid-sentence. Turns. “What?”
Emily repeats it too quietly for me to hear. Orlian’s attention leaves me completely.
I wait. Not deliberately, I'm simply still holding the answer to what she had just said. Thomas starts another conversation beside me. By the time Orlian looks back, Merren is asking Clara whether she remembers something about a broken window. The moment is gone. I let it go.
It happens again later.
Not with Orlian. With everyone. I start telling Thomas about a stablehand getting chased into a feed shed by Bramble and halfway through, Clara asks Merren where he put the bottle.
Merren answers. Emily interrupts because he apparently put it somewhere stupid. Thomas turns to defend him.
My story stops. Nobody notices.
A few minutes later, Merren glances at me. “Sorry, what happened to the stablehand?”
I look at him. He actually wants to know.
I shrug. “Nothing. He lived.”
“That was the ending?”
“Apparently.”
Merren smiles. Then Emily leans into his shoulder to reach the bottle and he forgets again.
It should bother me more than it does. Or less. Can't decide.
The sun lowers. The roof turns warmer and the air cooler. For a while, everyone talks about what comes next: advanced tutors, placements, families.
Thomas has apparently developed a complicated hatred of administrative law.
Clara is being trained in household management and social accounting and considers both crimes against her personally.
Merren is studying history and municipal systems.
Emily has three tutors and despises all of them for different reasons.
Orlian knows all of this.
More than that, she knows when Merren’s examinations are. She knows why Emily’s mother dismissed her correspondence tutor. She knows Thomas has been trying to avoid some dinner with his father’s associates.She knows Clara is considering switching instructors.
They know things about her too. I learn most of it by listening.
Once, Emily says, “Are you still going Thursday?”
Orlian says, “Probably.”
Neither explains Thursday.
Thomas asks whether “she” has written back.
Orlian says no.
Emily looks at her.
A whole conversation passes between their faces.
I drink my wine.
It isn't jealousy. I do not want what I wanted at twelve. Mostly. But I remember when Orlian used to lean toward me to whisper things she did not want Thomas hearing. I remember knowing what she meant when she rolled her eyes across a room.
Now Emily knows.
Fine.
People are allowed to become closer while I am busy disappearing.
The thought is sour enough that I drink again.
“Tuesday, then?” Thomas says.
Merren nods.
“If Bell doesn’t keep me late.”
“He will,” Clara says.
“Thank you.”
“You’re welcome.”
Emily says, “Come anyway. We can save you food.”
I look around.
“Tuesday?”
Thomas looks at me. “Oh.”
Emily recovers first. “We’re having dinner at mine.”
“You should come,” Clara says.
Merren nods. “Yes.”
Thomas adds, “Absolutely.”
Three separate invitations, all arriving after the fact.
I smile. “Clearly everyone was just waiting for my approval.”
Thomas winces slightly. I almost wish he wouldn't.
Emily says, “We only decided yesterday.”
That may be true. It probably is.
“I’m joking,” I assure them.
“Are you coming?” Clara asks.
“I don’t know.”
“Come.”
“Maybe.”
Thomas points at me.
“That means yes.”
“It absolutely does not.”
“It did when we were twelve.”
“When we were twelve I had fewer standards.”
“Again, glad you came.”
I smile.
The moment passes.
Mostly.
Emily bumps her knee against mine. “You are more like yourself.”
I look at her.
She smiles.
There is nothing cruel in it.
“What does that mean?”
Her smile falters. “Nothing bad.”
“I didn’t say it was.”
“You made the face.”
“What face?”
“The one you make when you’re about to bite.”
Merren says, “Bramble.”
I look at him.
He grins.
I laugh despite myself.
Emily relaxes. “I just mean... I don’t know. You seem better.”
“I am.” That answer is easier. Because... it
is true.
“I’m glad.”
She means that too.
Then Orlian says something about a Councilor’s assistant being caught with another man’s fiancée, and Emily whips around so fast I nearly lose the thread completely.
“What?”
Orlian looks pleased with herself. “You haven’t heard?”
“No.”
Clara has.
Of course Clara has.
She leans forward immediately. “That is not what happened.”
Thomas says, “It absolutely is.”
“You heard it from your brother.”
“My brother was there.”
“Your brother says he is everywhere.”
“He is socially gifted.”
“He is a disease.”
Merren starts laughing.
I settle back against the crate and listen.
The story changes three times before anyone reaches the end.
Apparently the councilor’s assistant was caught in a carriage.
Or a garden.
Or possibly nowhere at all.
Emily insists she heard the fiancée had actually broken the engagement weeks ago.
Thomas says nobody told her father.
Clara says that does not make it an affair.
Merren says it makes it poor planning.
Orlian tells all of them they are missing the interesting part.
“The interesting part,” she says, “is that by tomorrow half of Central Embrathis will swear she was carrying his child.”
Emily groans.
“People are disgusting.”
“People are bored,” Thomas says.
Clara lifts her cup. “They’ll believe anything if the story is better than the truth.”
“God,” Emily says, and gives a short laugh. “Remember that awful one about Raenie after Leah?”
Thomas turns toward her. “Emily.”
“What?”
His expression answers for him.
Emily looks from him to me, her mouth still half-curved from the conversation before.
“Oh, come on. She knows people talked.”
I do.
People had gone quiet when I walked into rooms. Mothers had drawn their children closer without seeming to. Conversations ended strangely around me for months.
I knew. I just stopped wondering what they were saying.
“What one?” I ask.
Emily hesitates.
Only then does she seem to understand that knowing there had been gossip is not the same thing as knowing what it was.
“It was horrible,” she says.
Thomas mutters, “Then perhaps leave it there.”
“But she asked.”
“Because you brought it up.”
“I know, Thomas.”
Merren reaches over for the bottle between them. “Excellent work from everyone.”
Emily shoots him a look. “No one asked you.”
“No one ever does. I persevere.”
Usually that would get a laugh.
This time it barely does.
Emily rubs the heel of her hand against her knee and looks at me again.
“They said Leah was panicking.”
For a second, I do not understand why she has said Leah’s name. Then I do.
The roof seems to sharpen around me.
“She was,” I say.
“I know.” Emily is speaking much more carefully now.
“That she was pulling you under.”
“She was five.”
“I know, Raenie.”
My fingers tighten slightly around my cup.
Emily sees it. AQSKeeps going anyway, because she has already come this far and apparently that is reason enough.
“And that you let her go.”
No one says anything.
Somewhere below us, wheels knock hard over a seam in the street.
The wind turns cooler against the side of my face.
I look down at my hand.
Wine shines along the inside of the cup when I tilt it. There is a little crescent of dirt beneath one thumbnail from the stable this morning.
Nothing else.
For one stupid second I expect river water.
I had her.
The thought comes whole.
I had her.
“Oh,” I say.
Emily looks miserable. “It was disgusting. I only meant because we were talking about rumors and that was probably the worst one I ever heard.”
Thomas shakes his head. “You could have demonstrated the concept with literally anything else.”
“I realize that now.”
“Remarkable.”
“Fuck off.”
Merren makes a quiet sound into his cup that might have been a laugh in another conversation.
Then Emily reaches over and touches my knee. “None of us believed it.”
I look at her.
She means to reassure me.
I can see that plainly enough.
Thomas is watching Emily with open irritation, not me. Merren’s mouth has gone tight in that particular way it does when he thinks someone is being stupid and is deciding whether saying so would improve matters.
Clara has gone very still.
Her thumb rises.
Slowly smooths over one eyebrow.
Her eyes drop with it.
My stomach goes cold.
It is such an old gesture.
Clara used to do it when she had copied the wrong answer and was insisting she had not. When her mother asked whether she knew where a missing bottle of brandy had gone. When she had read one of Orlian’s letters without permission and spent half an afternoon pretending innocence.
She catches herself halfway through.
Her hand drops.
I look at Orlian.
She is already looking at me.
For half a breath, neither of us moves.
Then her gaze slips off toward the city.
Not dramatically.
That would be kinder.
Just enough.
I take another drink.
“Of course not.” My voice sounds normal. Better than normal, perhaps.
Clara says, “Raenie.”
“It’s fine.”
“No, it isn’t.”
I look at her. “That’s reassuring. For a moment I was worried I’d have to decide for myself.”
Thomas closes his eyes.
Emily shifts beside me.
Clara’s face pinches.
“I didn’t mean it like that.”
“I know.”
Orlian finally says, “Raenie, I...”
I lift my cup slightly toward her. “Please don’t.”
She stops.
I smile. It feels wrong on my face, but it stays there. “We were thirteen. Obviously we were all experts on drowning.”
“Raenie,” Clara says again.
“What?” There is more bite in it this time.
She hears it.
So do I, so I smooth it over before anyone can touch it.
“Really. It’s fine.”
Emily looks at Clara.
Clara looks at Orlian.
Orlian looks at me.
I hate all three of them a little for that.
Not enough.
That would be easier.
Merren reaches for the bottle and pours more wine into his cup even though he has barely touched what was already there.
Thomas rubs both hands down his face.
“Well,” he says. “This has gone beautifully.”
A small laugh escapes me. It surprises everyone, especially me.
“There. See?” I lift my cup again. “Old times’ sake.”
Nobody drinks.
The conversation does not recover, not properly.
Thomas tries. He starts talking about Bell’s examinations. Merren answers. Clara says something. Someone laughs once, too loudly. Orlian barely speaks.
I stay.
That may be the stupidest part.
I stay because leaving immediately would make it a scene. I stay because I came here to prove I could. I stay because, despite everything, Thomas says something ten minutes later that makes me laugh.
Because Merren passes me the moonweed without looking. Because Clara’s knee touches mine and neither of us moves away. Because Emily asks whether I really might come Tuesday. Because Orlian eventually joins an argument again and, for a few minutes, I almost forget what her face looked like when the rumor came up.
Almost.
The sun finally slips behind the western roofs.
Twilight begins in earnest.
Someone lights a lantern near the hatch.
The little flame turns everybody softer than they deserve.
I stand.
Thomas looks up. “You going already?”
“My mother will assume I’ve joined a traveling circus if I miss dinner.”
“She’d be devastated.”
“She’d be relieved.”
Emily gets to her feet. “You should still come Tuesday.”
“Maybe.”
“That means yes.”
“That disease is spreading.”
Thomas smiles, small.
Clara stands too, and for a moment I think she might hug me again. She does not.
“I’m glad you came,” she says. There is an apology hiding under it.
I do not go looking.
“Me too.” That lie comes easily.
Emily squeezes my hand.
Merren lifts his cup toward me. “Next time I want the rest of the Bramble story.”
I arch a brow. “You forfeited it.”
“Cruel.”
“You’ll survive.”
Thomas points toward me as I step toward the hatch. “Don’t vanish for another three years.”
The words are light, mostly.
I look back at him. “I’ll put it on my schedule.”
He smiles, and he doesn't hear the edge. Or pretends not to.
Clara does. I can tell by her face.
Orlian has not moved from the parapet. Her eyes are on me. I look away first.
“Goodnight,” I say.
Several voices answer at once, not quite together.
I climb down through the hatch. The roof door closes above me. The voices disappear with it.
The stairwell is cooler now. The warmth of the roof falls away within a few steps, replaced by old stone and dust and the faint waxy smell of whatever they use on the classroom floors. My boots sound too loud.
I take the new way down.
I know it now. Three years gone and apparently I can still learn things.
Emily is an idiot.
Clara is a coward.
Orlian can go fuck herself.
I am fine.
The last one seems worth repeating.
I am fine.By the time I reach the bottom floor, I have almost managed to make it sound convincing.
Someone is still teaching in one of the rooms along the corridor. A man’s voice drones through a closed door, followed by the dry scratch of several pens. I pass without slowing. The front hall is empty except for a boy stacking books onto a cart beneath the windows.
He glances at me.
I glance back.
He decides the books are fascinating.
Outside, evening has finally overtaken the afternoon, not quite night yet.
The last sunlight still touches the upper floors across the street, but down between the buildings everything has gone blue and amber. Lamps burn behind shop windows. Someone is dragging a chalkboard sign inside a café. A pair of carriage horses stand steaming faintly at the curb while their driver argues with a man carrying three parcels and no apparent sense of urgency.
I turn left.
Home is right. I know this. My feet apparently do not.
The school stables sit only a few streets over, and I have nowhere I particularly need to be for another half hour.
My mother will disagree with this assessment, but she will survive.
I make it past the stationer’s before the door behind me opens. I hear it bang against the stop. Then quick footsteps hit the pavement. I do not turn. There are hundreds of people in this part of the city. Any one of them could be in an unnecessary hurry.
“Raenie!”
Damn it.
I stop. No, not immediately. I take one more step first, mostly because I am petty. Then I look back.
Orlian is coming down the pavement after me, actually coming after me. Not strolling. Not calling once and deciding she has done her civic duty.
She is hurrying hard enough that her coat has come open and the ends of her short hair are lifting around her face. She nearly clips shoulders with an older man walking the opposite direction, twists around him at the last second, mutters an apology, and keeps going.
Something old and humiliating stirs in my chest.
For the briefest instant, I am twelve again.
Twelve, and stupid enough that Orlian Fairchild-running-after-me-at-twilight would have been sufficient cause for my immediate death.
I once spent an entire supper pretending not to watch her mouth while she talked.
I had been an idiot, and the evidence continues to accumulate.
Orlian catches up to me near the corner, and she is a little breathless. I hate that too.
“Raenie.”
“You found me.”
She stares at me. “I watched you leave.”
“Less impressive, then.”
Her mouth tightens.
There it is.
That tiny shift I used to spend entire afternoons trying to provoke.
I turn and start walking again.
Orlian falls in beside me. “Can you stop for a minute?”
“I’m not walking particularly fast.”
“You know what I mean.”
“I usually do. It saves time.”
She makes a quiet, aggravated sound.
I almost smile.
Almost.
“Look,” she says.
I keep looking ahead.
People move around us in both directions, evening beginning properly now that shops are closing. A woman passes with a little girl by the hand. Two students in academy coats are arguing so fiercely about some examination result that one nearly walks straight into a lamp post.
Orlian waits until they pass. Then:
“I’m sorry.”
I nod. “So I gathered.”
“No, you didn’t.”
That gets my attention. I look at her. “What a strange thing to tell someone after apologizing.”
“I didn’t say anything upstairs.”
“You made quite a compelling face.”
“Raenie.”
“What?”
“I’m trying.”
I look ahead again. “That’s nice.”
She is quiet for several steps.
I can feel her looking at me. I wish she would stop. I wish she had never looked away on the roof. Both are apparently too much to ask.
“I should have asked you,” she says.
“Probably.”
“You could at least let me finish.”
“I did.”
“No, you gave me one word.”
I shrug, brows rising. “It was an excellent word.”
Her pace slows for half a second.
Mine does not.
“Are you going to do this the whole time?”
“Do what?”
“This.”
I glance over.
“Walk home?”
“You’re going the wrong direction.”
I look ahead. The stable road is two crossings away.
“Observant.”
“You live east.”
“I know where I live, Orlian.”
“Then where are you going?”
“Horses.”
Her brows draw together.
“What?”
“The stables.”
“Why?”
I shrug. “There are horses there.”
A beat.
Then, despite herself, Orlian laughs. It is small. Barely there. It makes something inside me loosen before I can stop it. I immediately resent her for that.
“There,” I say. “We’ve repaired everything. You can go back.”
“I’m not going back yet.”
“Your loss.”
She lets that sit.
Then, more carefully, “I heard what people were saying.”
There it is.
The city seems to recede without actually getting quieter.
I shove my hands into my coat pockets. “So did half of Embrathis, apparently.”
“I mean then.”
“I know what you mean.”
“I didn’t believe...” She stops.
I wait. Not because I am helping. Because she chose to follow me. She can suffer through constructing her own sentences.
Orlian tries again. “I never thought you wanted Leah hurt.”
I look at her. “That is an astonishingly low bar.”
“I know.”
The answer lands badly because there is no defense in it. I turn forward again.
She continues. “I heard she panicked. That she was climbing on you and pushing you under.”
“She was drowning.”
“I know.”
“She was five.”
“I know.”
“You keep saying that.”
“Because I do.” The sharpness in her voice makes me look over.
She is frustrated now. Good. I understand frustration. It is much easier than whatever she was doing before.
Orlian takes a breath through her nose. “I thought maybe you let go because you couldn’t keep both of you up.”
I nod slowly. “Very charitable.”
“Can you not?”
“Not what?”
“Make it sound worse than I meant it.”
I laugh. There is nothing especially funny in the sound. “I’m not sure I’m the one doing that.”
Her face flushes.
She looks away.
We reach the crossing and have to wait while a carriage turns through.
For a few seconds we stand shoulder to shoulder beneath a newly lit streetlamp.
Her sleeve brushes mine.
I notice. Of course I do. Apparently humiliation has a very long half-life.
The carriage clears. I cross. Orlian comes with me. Fuck's sake.
“I was thirteen,” she says.
“So was I.”
“I know.”
“Good. For a moment I worried the rumor had improved my age too.”
“Raenie.”
“What?”
“You’re angry.”
I scoff. “God, these advanced tutors are miraculous.”
She stops walking.
I get three steps ahead before I realize.
I turn. Orlian stands in the middle of the pavement looking at me with her jaw set. People split around her.
“What?” I ask.
“Can you stop doing that?”
“Standing?”
“The jokes.”
“They’re not all jokes.”
“That’s worse.”
I tilt my head. “Would you prefer I shout?”
“No.”
“Cry?”
“No.”
“Excellent. Then we’ve narrowed it down.”
Her expression changes. I know instantly that one got too close. I turn before she can answer and start walking again.
She catches up. Of course she does.
“You disappeared,” she says.
I glance sideways. There is no accusation in her voice. That does not stop it from sounding like one.
“I’m aware.”
“We did try.”
“I know.”
“Clara came all the time.”
“I know.”
“Thomas sent notes.”
“I know.”
“Merren sent you books for months.”
“I know.”
“I came.”
That one makes my steps falter. Barely. Orlian sees it anyway.
“I know,” I say again.
“You wouldn’t see me.”
My mouth goes dry.
I look toward a shop window as we pass it. Ink bottles, paper, sealing wax, a row of little brass nibs catching lamplight.
“I wasn’t seeing much of anyone.”
“I know.”
“You don’t sound like you know.”
“What am I supposed to say?”
I look at her.
She looks genuinely irritated now. Not offended. Not wounded. Just tired of the shape of this conversation.
“I don’t know,” I say. “You’re the one who followed me.”
“That doesn’t mean I prepared remarks.”
“Terrible leadership.”
“What?”
“Nothing.”
She shakes her head.
We walk another few steps.
Then she says, “Eventually I stopped coming.”
I say nothing.
“So did everyone else.”
Still nothing.
“I’m sorry.”
That is harder to make into a joke. I try anyway.
“Efficient, really. Saved everyone a great deal of walking.”
“Raenie.”
“I stopped answering.”
She goes quiet.
There. I pull my hands farther into my pockets.
“I know I did.” The words feel unpleasantly bare without anything sharp around them. So I add, “I was very committed to being unbearable.”
“You weren’t unbearable.”
I snort. “I assure you, I was.”
“You were miserable.”
That shuts me up. Orlian keeps her eyes on the road. She says it like it is obvious. No great tenderness. No revelation. Just a fact. I do not know what to do with it.
For a while, we walk without speaking.
The stable quarter begins to announce itself before we reach it. The streets widen slightly. A wagon loaded with hay turns across the next intersection. There is a warm animal smell beneath the city smoke. A horse somewhere ahead gives a high, impatient whinny.
My shoulders drop a fraction.
Orlian notices that too. She notices too much. Maybe she always did. Maybe she's only just noticing things for the first time. I don't know if I care or not.
“I missed you,” she says.
I nearly trip over absolutely nothing. I recover before she can enjoy it.
“Did you?”
“Yes.”
“Hm.”
“Don’t.”
“I didn’t say anything.”
“You made a noise.”
“I’m allowed.”
She rubs a hand over her face. “This is exhausting.”
“I did warn you.”
“No, you didn’t.”
“I implied it.”
“That’s not the same thing.”
“It is when I do it.”
For a second she actually smiles. I see it from the corner of my eye.
Then she says, “I did miss you.”
Again.
As though repetition will make the sentence less inconvenient.
Once, I would have traded an embarrassing amount for those words. I remember sitting beside her on the old roof with my knee pressed against hers and refusing to move first. I remember the time she whispered something about our history tutor against my ear because Thomas was close enough to overhear, and I spent the entire walk home furious that a human voice could apparently do that to my spine. I remember Clara catching me watching Orlian at some winter supper and smiling so knowingly that I kicked her under the table.
Now Orlian has followed me into the evening street to tell me she missed me.
The timing is almost impressive.
“You had my address,” I say.
There.
Not quite a joke.
Orlian looks down.
“I know.”
I had expected an argument. Something about unanswered notes. Something about my mother turning people away. Anything I could push against.
Instead: “I should have tried longer.”
I stare at her.
She keeps walking.
I hate that answer. I hate that some part of me wants to forgive her for giving it.
“That sounds exhausting,” I say.
“Probably.”
“You had better things to do.”
“Yes.”
I look at her sharply. She lifts one shoulder. “You did too, eventually.”
For some reason, that almost makes me laugh. Not because it is funny. Because it is so ordinary.
We were children.
Then we were older children.
She found other people.
I found horses.
Clara learned to lie with her eyebrow and apparently never fixed it.
Thomas acquired a criminal hat.
Merren learned the roof better than I knew it.
Emily learned exactly what she could whisper into Orlian’s ear to make her stop mid-argument.
Life went on while I was not looking at it.
“Your hair is terrible,” I say.
Orlian turns to me.
“What?”
“The haircut.”
She stares.
I keep my face completely straight.
“I’ve been thinking it all evening.”
Her mouth opens. Then closes. “You liked it long. Liked
me when it was long.”
I hate her. "Don't get too far ahead of yourself."
“You absolutely did.”
“That was three years ago.”
“You stared at me.”
“I stared at everyone.”
“No, you didn’t.”
I can feel heat climbing my neck. Wonderful. Absolutely wonderful.
“This conversation has ended.”
Orlian laughs, actually laughs this time. Bright enough that a man passing us glances over.
For half a second, I am annoyed for an entirely different reason.
Because I remember that sound. Because I still like it. Because somewhere beneath all the rest of this, being beside her is not difficult.
It should be. That would make leaving easier.
We reach the next corner.
The school buildings are behind us now. The road toward the stables continues west, broad and darkening. If we turn back, the annex roof is only a few minutes away.
Orlian slows.
“Come back.”
I look at her.
“To the roof.”
“I don't know.”
“Thomas has probably found another hat by now.”
“Then he deserves privacy.”
“I’m serious.”
I stop.
She stops with me. Lanternlight falls warm across one side of her face. The rest is blue with evening. It is annoyingly romantic. I resent the entire street.
“You left,” she says. “I came after you. I apologized badly. You insulted my hair. We can go back now.”
I almost smile.
“That’s your argument?”
“Yes.”
“It’s weak.”
“I had less time to prepare than I expected.”
I glance back the way we came. The annex itself is hidden behind the nearer buildings now. But I know exactly where the roof is. Exactly who is sitting there.
Thomas will be trying too hard to make everyone laugh.
Emily will be pretending the whole thing was less awful than it was.
Clara will be miserable.
Merren will probably be drinking someone else’s wine because he finished his without noticing.
There would be room if I went back.
Not the same room. Not the same shape. Still room.
Orlian waits. She does not beg. Does not reach for my hand. Does not tell me everything will be different now. She just waits long enough that I know she means the invitation.
I look west again.
“I think I’ve had enough old times for one day.”
Her expression falls slightly.
“It doesn’t have to be old times.”
I look back at her.
That catches somewhere inconvenient. So I shrug.
“New times sound like work.”
“They probably are.”
“Hard sell.”
“Raenie.”
I smile.
“It’s fine.”
Her face closes a little. Not much. Enough. “Stop saying that.”
“What would you prefer?”
“The truth would be novel.”
I raise my eyebrows. “Careful. You’ve known me too long to start expecting miracles.”
“I mean it.”
“I know.”
There is a beat.
Then another.
I can feel the conversation trying to become something I do not know how to have. So I step backward toward the stable road.
Orlian lets me.
“Are you coming Tuesday?” she asks.
I blink.
“Emily’s.”
“I remember.”
“Are you?”
“Maybe.”
Something about her face softens. “That used to mean yes.”
“People change.”
“So I’ve noticed.”
The answer slips out before either of us seems prepared for it. I look at her. She looks like she wants to take it back.
I save her the trouble. “Apparently.”
I turn.
“Raenie.”
I stop.
Look over my shoulder.
Orlian has not moved. For once, she does not seem to be deciding what everyone else should do next.
“I was wrong.”
That is all.
No explanation.
No appeal.
Just the sentence.
I have several answers ready. None of them survive long enough to reach my mouth.
“Okay.” It comes out quieter than I intend.
Orlian nods.
I start walking again.
She does not follow this time.
The road widens another block down, and the smell of hay gets stronger. Horses shift somewhere beyond the stable wall, tack clinking softly as someone finishes putting the last of them away for the evening.
I tell myself not to look back.
I make it nearly to the stable gate before I do.
Orlian is gone.
I stand there for half a second anyway. My throat tightens.
Then I push through the gate.